Preyssler-type polyoxometalates (POMs) encapsulating lanthanide ions have been shown to provide ideal examples of single-molecule magnets and spin-qubits. However, the advances in this area are limited by the quality and size of the crystals. In this work, the role of additives ions in the crystallization of these POMs from aqueous solutions has been investigated. More specifically, we have studied the influence of Al3+, Y3+, and In3+ on the crystallization process of K12[MP5W30O110] (where M = Gd and Y). The results show that the concentration of these ions in the solution plays an important role in controlling the crystallization rate of the grown POM crystals leading to a significant increase in their size, while showing very little or no tendency to be incorporated into the structure. This has allowed us to obtain pure Gd or Y crystals, as well as diluted magnetic crystals formed by the diamagnetic Y3+ POM doped with the magnetic Gd3+ ion.